SONGS OF WARS I HAVE SEEN (Heiner Goebbels): 2018 Fringe review

Songs-of-War_4276-1200x800Heiner Goebbels’s celebrated SONGS OF WARS I HAVE SEEN has been touring world capitals since 2009, with pairings of different musical ensembles in each city. A Brechtian-tinged deconstructionist has constructed an imaginatively textured musical performance in which music, sounds, and speaking are of a piece. It is based on the war memoir Gertrude Stein wrote after leaving her famed Paris digs and moving out to the countryside, which came under the control of Vichy French (Nazi) collaborators.

Anu Tali, a woman with a long blonde ponytail and exceptional poise, conducts. The women musicians of baroque orchestra Tempesta di Mare and Philadelphia Orchestra, dressed in bright colors, are foregrounded on the stage. Men from the orchestras, MIB’s (Men in Black), are seated behind and above the women. Women musicians take turns reading short selections from the memoir.  The harpist (not listed in the program) sometimes sings softly. These musicians are not in traditional orchestra sections. Each, essentially a soloist, is seamlessly incorporated into the overall design.

Edison bulbs and mellow lights glowing under old lamp shades warm the stage… but sometimes it’s bright. David Bilger, principal trumpet, plays a beautiful, moody yet austere solo. Splendid, melodious music issues from strings, brass, percussion, grand piano, keyboard, harpsichord, arch lute, flute, synthesizer and eventually from bowls that, when stirred, resonate like muted bells. Music interacts with the spoken word, which somehow infuses the piece with philosophy. But sometimes the music is strident, not softly melodious.

This strikingly original performance is not so much exciting as it is a covert, experiential rumination on war, the somberness of war. The music pushes the scattered words and they seep into our heads. Gertrude Stein‘s small, gently ironic observations are reverberations of the rumblings of war on domestic life— like lack of food, the cold, and “anything like that.” “Everything is dangerous, life and death and death and life.” She approaches subjects such as “young Frenchmen who are not there anymore,” and there’s quiet terror in an oblique reference to Jews, “how anyone can be taken away.” SONGS OF WARS I HAVE SEEN is a cautionary tale and a brooding reflection by Heiner Goebbels, by Gertrude Stein, by the musicians, and in turn, a reflection by us.

[FringeArts, 140 N. Columbus Boulevard] September 7-8, 2018;


Fringe Festival, Fringe reviews, Music, Reviews - Tags: , , , , , , - no comments

About the author

Kathryn Osenlund, theater and film junkie, is a former National Critics Institute fellow, NEA fellow in Arts Journalism, and member of the American Theater Critics Assn Steinberg and Osborn playwriting awards committee. A Barrymore Award nominator and professor emeritus in communications and theater, Kathryn also writes for NY-based On twitter @theatrendorphin.